Voir les contributions
Cette section vous permet de consulter les contributions (messages, sujets et fichiers joints) d'un utilisateur. Vous ne pourrez voir que les contributions des zones auxquelles vous avez accès.
À ce propos, tu aurais pu boucler une sacrée boucle, en n'ayant pas joué le GP 2008, si tu avais joué ce GP 2024 !!!
D'ailleurs, physiquement, au final il n'y a bien que toi (sami et géo aussi je dois dire) qui n'ont pas vraiment changé en 15 ans
Et enfin, j'avais adoré le CDE 2008, mais j'étais resté frustré de ne pas avoir pu participer ni voir la partie GP 150 (ayant dû partir avant la fin des 4 jours) et cette frustration je l'ai comblée cette année avec le CDM 2024,car oui j'ai pu assister en spectateur très discret sur toute la phase finale du GP de 18h à 01h du matin. Ça a bcp changé, vous avez bcp changé hahaha (+ bcp de personnes que je ne connaissais mm pas de nom) , c'était très pro et très agréable à regarder. J'ai kiffé !
Après si j'ai pu venir à vernon c'est aussi que j'habite dans l'Eure moi aussi (à 30 min du CDM) donc je ne pouvais pas louper ça (c'est bien sûr peut être aussi une des raisons pour laquelle j'ai repris le TT) . Vous êtes au top, c'est super que la flamme de smk continue de briller !
), et du coup tu es à moins d'une seconde du WR sans boosts 
Je sais que je suis hors délais
I've no bias on this but it would be nice for it to be tested for my return in 2025. Until then I wish you all the very best of luck at what will be a fabulous event in a couple of weeks.
The deadline for feedback/opinions is July 31.
Now that it's July and we're roughly halfway through the discussion period for this topic, I want to provide some insight into my current evaluation of the discussion and what it would look like in terms of decision-making based on the feedback so far. This way there is still time for further conversations prior to finalizing this year's ruleset.Very solid points there, nothing to add. I only want to react to 3 specific points:
For reference, my general stance is that the decision to be made on these different ruleset matters is primarily driven by majority opinion. However, if there's no clear majority (i.e. it's close to a 50/50 split in opinion), then I would err on the side of conserving the existing rule when applicable. There's also a consideration to be had with regards to who is impacted by a given rule. In that sense, I would give a lower-ranked player's opinion more weight with regards to something like "Should BM/MR group stage matches change to 6 rounds instead of 4?" rather than something like "Should a bracket reset impact the point allocation for the players in the final?"
I know that the consequences of having three groups with regards to bracket seeding aren't great, but I also think that there are certain participant counts for which three groups are the only viable option. I think that we should guarantee at least 10 matches per player in group stage (especially given that Round Robin is faster to run than Swiss). This means that we shouldn't have four groups with fewer than 44 players. On the flip side, it's less clear to me what we should allow as the maximum number of matches. Keep in mind that the larger that number, the smaller the range in which we'd need to use three groups.Have you tried to figure out what would be the largest possible number of matches, especially in BM/GP, without making things too long?
I think that what I would go for currently is to disallow retry petitions from players. In parallel, I think that we should improve the logistics of LKS so that we have vigilant staff who can issue a retry due to external interference. Of course, the staff part would require some additional discussion and coordination to make sure that actually happens at CDM.Entirely agree with that "vigilant staff" part, considering that I've advocated this in my initial answer. I have no problem with retry petitions being forbidden as long as there's somebody able to tell if there was something disturbing us or not (but more importantly, making sure there's nothing).
GP tiebreaker will be changed to points scored instead of point differential.
I'll let you choose this year's rules. I'll take care of the rest of the organisation, I trust you with that.
I've never taken the time to study the rules in depth, I've got all kinds of other things to prepare and it's a lot of work.
Le mieux étant peut être que les gens du staff ne soient pas des gens qui souhaitent participer peut être, mais il faudrait trouver des volontaires (et ça, je comprends que ça ne soit pas facile)
It is also important to note that the arbiter giving you the go-ahead is mostly so you don't interrupt the previous player. So, when you get the go ahead you can take a bit of time to check your surroundings, wait a bit if need be, and make sure you are happy before you go.
It also disincentivizes top players from trolling the living daylights out of people that are already struggling to rank in.